It took me two clicks to find this very extensive article on foil backs, complete with references from Cellini to the present:
The author is a gemologist and proprietor of a gem antique business in Londonâs Hatton Garden District.
Let me add this as a gem cutterâŚif a faceted stone is well cut, you wonât see thru it when it is viewed face onâŚwith low RI stones, even up to RI=1.76 (topaz and corundum are in this range) there is going to be the beginning of some windowing at about 10 to 15 degrees tilt off axis when the stone is viewed at the normal viewing distance for a ring. This occurs mostly because of whatâs called the âhead shadow effectâ. Rays of light enter the gemstone perpendicular to the table around the head and are returned to the eye, but light rays blocked by the head and neck result in no light return, hence the window you see. Higher RI gems, esp. diamonds and CZ do not window, esp. in round stones or other symmetrical.
cuts.
Now all that said, many commercial gemstones are still cut with incorrect angles, which means they window even face up. There is often a collar of brilliance from the crown facets, but the table is completely dead. This occurs because commercial cutters belly the pavilion to add weight to the stone and sacrifice brilliance and best color to that end. This is so even thoâ we have now known about proper angles for cutting diamonds since Tolkowsky studied the SRB cut for diamonds in 1919 and since Long and Steele computed correct angles for hundreds of facet cuts for colored stones using Texas Instruments calculators in the 1980âs, colored stones could be cut to correct angles, too. There are now several computer programs that virtually cut stones and can show you animations of what properly cut stones look likeâŚall of which reduces or eliminates the problems that require foil backs, which just donât last forever.
As far as cabochons go, yes, you can often see thru them. If the stone is dark, it isnât too much of an issue. Cabochons which are translucent reduce this problem, as you canât see thru them completely and they seem to glow s light diffuses thru them. I have some aqua now that is too cloudy to facet, but I think it is going to make some killer cabs, even if these will not be highly valued.
I saw some discussion of using stainless steel rings with a mirror of stainless behind the cab stones on one of the old faceting forumsâŚthe idea being that the stainless would not tarnish much. I suppose you could use the newer tarnish resistant silver alloysâŚperhaps Pt would not tarnish much? Or read the link above about the Old World foiling techniques.
If anyone is interested in modern optimized facet designs, I am happy to discuss this. DM me. I have been faceting on and off since 1996 and have done more virtual cutting than cutting of real stones. Many faceters and facet designers use the same angles for a design in any species, claiming that you donât really have to optimize for each type of stone, but I disagree and I optimize differently for lighter colored stones than darker colors and differently for tourmaline, say, vs rhodolite. I can see a difference in the light performance. If you know what to look for, you will, too. Beth apparently doesnât like windows in stones, and neither do I. She hit the ball right down my alley. I may have some comparison stones to show soon. -royjohn