Success!! I managed to get the original recipe to work, but I had to get it not just warm, but hot, hot, hot. . .just under a boil. Funny thing is that I’m not entirely certain of what it is doing. On the one hand, it is supposed to be depletion gilding the surface by removing the silver (for the most part). If that was the case, I would’ve expected the surface to end up somewhat frosted, but it isn’t. The polish is still there, but the green is gone.
A few notes, this was done in a pyrex container and the only other metal introduced was a wire of the same 18K green gold alloy to suspend the piece with. So I know nothing was contaminated and I don’t think anything is being plated (ala copper plating after iron has been dropped in the pickle), but I do find it strange that the finish is being preserved even though I’m getting rid of the greener tones.
Well, either way, I’m happy to have figured it out and learned a fair amount along the way. Thanks everyone for the help! As always, it’s much appreciated!
Erich